The Learning Challenge, or Learning Pit, created by James Nottingham, promotes challenge, dialogue and a growth mindset. It is one way to make challenge more appealing to learners. It gives a frame of reference to talk about learning and also helps with planning, reviewing and metacognition. Learners are said to be “in the pit” when they are in a state of “cognitive conflict” (i.e. when learners have two or more ideas that make sense to them but which, on reflection, are in conflict with each other).
· It begins with a concept, which can come from the media, conversation, observations or the curriculum. So long as students have at least some understanding of the concept then the Learning Challenge can work.
· The key to the Learning Challenge is to get students “into the pit” by creating cognitive conflict in their minds. This deliberate creation of a dilemma is what makes the Learning Challenge such a good model for challenge and inquiry. It is also the frequent experience of cognitive conflict that helps to build a Growth Mindset (Dweck, 2006) in the minds of Learning Challenge participants.
· After a while of being “in the pit”, some students begin to construct meaning for themselves. They do this by identifying relationships, explaining causes and integrating ideas into a new structure. As they do this, they experience a sense of “eureka” in which they have a new sense of clarity. This in turn puts them in an ideal position to help those students who are still confused.
· Once “out of the pit”, students should be encouraged to reflect on the stages of thinking they’ve just been through – from a single, simplistic idea (stage 1) to the identification of lots of, sometimes conflicting, ideas (stage 2), right through to a new understanding of more complex and inter-related ideas (stage 3). They should then consider ways to relate and apply their new understanding to different contexts.